Style Fusion

The modern-day composer often has to write in a variety of styles, from world traditions to electronic, from glorious harmony to, well, glorious atonality. Like many have said, composers have to be chameleons, putting on a variety of masks to cater to the situation at hand. Film composers have had to figure out how to write for metallic art sculptures, cactuses, vegetables and pens; how to perfectly mimic music from other ethnicities while remaining relevant to the score; how to incorporate popular music elements without sounding clichéd; and above all, developing a unique sound for each film while simultaneously placing their sonic ’stamp’ on each to maintain their own voice.

This is something I’ve had to come to grips with: learning how to orchestrate and create suave, diatonic melodies is not the final step in the journey to being a successful composer. Not by a longshot. As a film composer, this covers probably less than half of your total output. The rest entails such things as atonal, aleatoric, and sound effect or synthscape music, music for various ethnicities or time periods, as well as smaller instrumental groups, and writing for nonstandard instruments. Ugh, the very word atonal gives me shivers. But, it’s just another area that needs to be researched and mastered. Like anything worth doing, it takes time and effort.

Below is a collection of snippets where the composers diverged drastically from their pre-established sound.


Randy Newman: “Opening Race”, Cars (2006)

  • Once again, Newman proves that he can’t be stereotyped into the folk song genre, effortlessly switching between traditional orchestra and rock ensemble.

Audio clip: Adobe Flash Player (version 9 or above) is required to play this audio clip. Download the latest version here. You also need to have JavaScript enabled in your browser.

David Arnold: “Welcome to Cuba”, Casino Royale (2006)

  • While there is no style-switching within this clip, this track alone stands out as the furthest deviation on the album as a whole. In this case, it’s questionable how much of this cue Arnold actually composed; as a piano player, he could have written the head and performed on it. It’s possible that to get that characteristic Southern flair, he relied more on the ensemble’s sound than on his compositional choicies (most of it was improvised). Nevertheless, Arnold obviously did his research in creating this piece.

Audio clip: Adobe Flash Player (version 9 or above) is required to play this audio clip. Download the latest version here. You also need to have JavaScript enabled in your browser.

John Williams: “Journey to Akator” from Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull (2008)

  • “Akator” follows the above example almost as precisely, although more of it is dependent on the actual written score than the performer’s experience. Given that the transition happens mid-cue, the effect is all the more striking.

Audio clip: Adobe Flash Player (version 9 or above) is required to play this audio clip. Download the latest version here. You also need to have JavaScript enabled in your browser.

BT: “Main Title”, Stealth (2005)

  • In all the above examples, the composers all started from an orchestral sound, then moved into their other style. Here, it happens in the reverse order: synth artist BT starts with the electronic version of the theme, then incorporates the orchestra. But in this case, the effect isn’t nearly as captivating: by already using a blend of acoustic and electronic sounds (likely all software-generated), when the brass comes in, it sounds sampled, too! The effect of the transition could’ve been made more effective by engineering a more dramatic shift in timbre, rather than just layering the horns on top of an already pseudo-acoustic sounding mix.

Audio clip: Adobe Flash Player (version 9 or above) is required to play this audio clip. Download the latest version here. You also need to have JavaScript enabled in your browser.

James Horner: “Collecting the Ballots” from The Legend of Zorro (2005)

  • Horner’s career has been one of the most vibrant and diverse in terms of musical styles. The entire Zorro score stands out as a departure from Horner’s more standard stuff, if you can call it that. This cue, the first of the album, features an ensemble of tap dancers, and a trio of flamenco guitarists, interspersed with elements of the more traditional orchestra.

Audio clip: Adobe Flash Player (version 9 or above) is required to play this audio clip. Download the latest version here. You also need to have JavaScript enabled in your browser.


In all, these moments of departure are among the most interesting to listen to from the composers. It’s a real skill to be able to take one’s musical style and plug it into a variety of different outlets. This is one ability common to the great composers of history.

Tags:

On Preplanning Pieces

How much of a piece should be pre-planned before you start writing it? Here’s a few possible methods:

  • Pre-planning everything: not writing a note before you have the entire piece figured out. This is the way Mozart worked. I tried this once, and while it did turn out a well-rounded piece, I would have preferred not banging my head against a wall and staring hopelessly at a blank page for hours on end.
  • Pre-planning nothing: while working this way could mean that you start writing right away, it also comes with its own caveats. Namely, if you don’t have an idea, or if you forget the idea along the way, you’re lost. I had a frustrating time with this while working on my first album; I was constantly aggravated by how I was unable to see more than about 3 bars ahead of where I was. I guess that if you want to be successful with this method you’ve got to always keep mulling over the idea, so that it becomes fully developed, with no corner left unexplored.
  • Working by revision: as Dan Visconti points out, sometimes the best way of composing is to plough through an entire rough draft, using notes as ‘placeholders’, which relieves a huge amount of stress in the end because now you can see the overall form of the piece, and zero in on those sections which need work. Another spin on this particular method is working out the short score, then going back and filling out the instruments. In the end, I find this method the most comforting, as the overall shape of the piece is solidified in the early stages, and the constant revision ensures that your ideas become fully developed.

Read: Composing Like a Painter, by Dan Visconti

Michael Giacchino: “Tepui Landing”, Up (2009)

Being one of the many Up fans who actively eats up any promotional material Pixar releases, I’ve of course watched the clip labelled ‘Tepui Landing’. And of course, I was trying to pay attention to Giacchino’s music when it came in.

image

When the fog clears, we’re presented with a vista which—in high-definition 3D theatres—should be nothing short of magnificent. What seemed odd about this 1930s, Hermannesque-type music was how small it seemed in comparison with the huge vista being shown onscreen. The ensemble can’t be more than about 30 people (about a third the size of a modern studio orchestra) and the sense of depth is practically zero with the lack of reverb. (Listen to some Zbigniew Preisner to hear an example of very ‘wet’ reverb.) What’s going on here, Giacchino? Surely you know better than this?

He does. In a video interview, Giacchino stated that his intent with the score for Up was to present music that the protagonist, Carl, would have listened to throughout his lifetime. Brilliant! Giacchino has chosen a musical ‘lens’ with which to frame his subject matter, in this case, the vista. And now it makes sense: the music for this scene is only a small sample from the palette that Giacchino is drawing on to paint a deeper picture of the main character. Throughout the rest of the movie, we’ll hear some swing, some Golden Age… maybe even some rock and roll if Carl is so inclined!

While it may seem counter-intuitive to this scene, if the rest of the music functions as he’s described, then it will succeed as an integrated, yet diverse musical work that enhances the story. All that’s left is to see if it plays out—I know that I for one am going to enjoy this moment.

Sources:

Tags:

Want more? World of Goo sheet music now available

So, as if World of Goo’s creator releasing the soundtrack for free wasn’t good enough, now we have Sebastian Wolff to thank for creating a full piano arrangement for every track! Yay free stuff!!

WOG-piano

Tags: ,

Mike Romaniak: “Sfumato”

Fellow U of T composer Mike Romaniak has just released a video from his latest work, entitled Sfumato. Without giving anything away, I’ll tell you that the word sfumato has something to do with blended layers, almost like smoke… check it out!

Tags:

John Williams: “The Mission”, NBC Nightly News

John Williams was first commissioned to write new opening orchestral music for the NBC Nightly News in 1985. He responded with four separate pieces including The Mission, which was re-recorded in 2006 in the video to come.

This work is a great example of Williams’s strengths as a composer. Mainly, his ability to latch onto the underlying emotions of the particular scenario he’s engaging with, whether it be the concert hall, film, or television. This is part of the reason why he’s such a successful film composer: by not stating the obvious but instead seeking to communicate that which the picture has left unsaid, he brings a new depth of character and emotion to the table. This keen perceptiveness is complemented by his skill at writing memorable themes that are entirely appropriate to the music’s emotional intent. And finally, like any good composer, he provides a sense of accomplishment and arrival by taking us on a journey of emotional peaks and valleys, fully exploiting the dramatic potential of the idea. Can you tell I’m a fan yet?

The Mission is constructed from one primary theme, a rhythmic ostinato, and two secondary motifs:

imageimage

imageimage

imageimage

The ostinato in the strings at the outset seems to suggest the hustle and bustle of everyday events, acting as a sort of greeting to someone who might be feeling a little anxious or high-strung. The motif heard in bar 3 occurs in three primary areas throughout the piece. This angular, disjunct theme could represent the job of the media in keeping on top of unfolding situations. The main theme itself is warming and mostly stepwise, moving smoothly through several keys before returning to the tonic, in a similar manner to Williams’s flying theme from E.T. The final element in the mix—the descending four-note motif—adequately fills in during the long notes of the main theme, and adds a quality of playfulness throughout the piece.

What we have here is a condensed work consisting of the four elements described above. The rest is just filler material. Have a listen, paying attention to their uses throughout the piece:

After getting through the main theme, Williams wastes no time in moving into the next section—the build—with the introduction of the snare drum. The next thirty seconds consists of the two motives in conversation, gradually growing in texture and dynamics, their intermingling creating a swelling sense of excitement.

Next comes my favourite part. At 1:53, just as we’re expecting a huge crash and a full-blown statement of the theme, Williams removes the entire bottom end and the orchestra becomes airborne. We’re soaring. For me, this is the point where the music transcends it’s purpose as opening music for the news, and bridges the gap between television screen and viewer. There’s a certain bond there that can only be achieved with music. I mean, this is what it’s all about: breaking down barriers, and reaching people in a way that nothing else can. I hate to say it like this, but when it works, it’s magic.

After this, we have a cool-down period of sorts, with the first motif heard throughout the woodwind section, accompanied by the ostinato which has been reworked to fit into the major triad. Next comes a short build up to a tasteful stop, before the final presentation of the beginning of the theme and first motif.


It’s clear that Williams’s intent with The Mission is to soften us up by the time the news starts. This is evident by his shift to using woodwinds for the theme near the conclusion, the gradual diminuendo, as well as by the use of the ostinato and motifs as functions of a major chord, rather than the established minor at the beginning.

The only criticism I have about The Mission is its ending. With such a clear trend in winding down, the last staccato chord sticks out like a sharp nail. Theoretically, you could justify its existence if it was set up by a similar staccato chord earlier, but no such chord exists. Or, perhaps if the work was becoming progressively more energetic it would feel more appropriate. But even despite the final fanfare, the overall emotional direction is clearly going the other way, bringing the listener down to a sense of calmness and peace that they didn’t have when the piece started. I’d say that this is a safe bet on what Williams was trying to do all along: helping us to relax and gain a clear mind before absorbing the subsequent barrage of information. And if that’s what his intentions were, then he should have chosen something more appropriate then a jarring, somewhat clichéd ending. This is only a minor annoyance, on the whole, the work is easily digestable, carefully thought out, and entirely relevant for its future function.

A few more parting thoughts, mostly from looking at the video: isn’t the camera work spectacular? They didn’t miss anything. Now, I realize that the footage was spliced together from several different takes, but when was the last time you saw footage of musicians on film or TV that matched—note for note—what you were hearing in the audio track? I mean, the glockenspiel notes all line up, the horn fingerings are all there, even Williams’s cueing mirrors what’s happening in the music. Kudos to the editor on this one. Overall, this piece is an excellent case study in writing integrated, well-rounded concert works. This is the challenge of composing: making a lot come out of a little.

Sources:

Tags: ,

Free soundtrack, anyone…?

For the videogame-savvy, those familiar with the smash hit World of Goo will appreciate the release of the complete in-game soundtrack. It’s remarkable how Gabler, one of the two people involved in the game’s production, found time to create such a diverse soundtrack. Most of the pieces average over three minutes in length, and the quality of the mix is generally very good. It’s worth mentioning that it’s suited to the game incredibly well, infusing it with a degree of eerie quirkiness that plays off the game’s visuals. This is yet another example of how limiting the number of people involved in the creative process leads to an overall higher degree of uniformity (see previous post.)

Tags: